Oscar Switcheroo

Every year there seems to be at least one nominee that just doesn't belong (oftentimes there are more). So I decided to look back over the last few years, and replace one nominee with another film I feel was more deserving.

2006 Nominees:
The Departed
Little Miss Sunshine
Letters from Iwo Jima
The Queen

Remove: Little Miss Sunshine
Replacament: Children of Men

Little Miss Sunshine may be cute, but it doesn't hold a candle to Alfonso Cuaron's dystopian nightmare about a not-too-distant future where women are infertile and the world has descended into chaos. Cuaron's film is one that will one day be taught in film classes, while Little Miss Sunshine will be remembered as a charming box office success story that got caught up in its own hype.

2005 Nominees:
Brokeback Mountain
Good Night, and Good Luck

Remove: Crash
Replacement: King Kong

Don't get me wrong, Crash was good. But hindsight on the film has not been kind. It's a film of Big Ideas, yes. But not confident enough to let them speak for themselves, director Paul Haggis handles the material with all the subtlety of a sledgehammer. Peter Jackson's remake of King Kong on the other hand features a surprising amount of subtlety for a massive epic adventure. It may be grand old fashioned filmmaking on an enourmous scale, but Jackson keeps the focus intimate and emotional, and in the process reminds us all why we go to the movies in the first place.

2004 Nominees:
The Aviator
Finding Neverland
Million Dollar Baby

Remove: Ray
Replace with: Dogville

Very few of those films actually deserved to make the top 5, but of the chosen nominees, Ray is the most problematic. Ray got off to a good start, and features a terrific performance by Jamie Foxx, who is surrounded by a very talented ensemble cast, but it stumbles by the end, finishing up like a made-for-TV movie, completely washing over the dramatic build-up. Lars von Trier's dark, brilliant study of human nature, Dogville, on the other hand, pushes cinema into places it has never gone before. It is new, daring, and fresh, where Ray is conventional and familiar.

2003 Nominees:
The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King
Lost in Translation
Master and Commander: The Far Side of the World
Mystic River

Remove: Seabiscuit
Replacement: In America

Seabiscuit may quite possibly be the most inexplicable Best Picture nominee of the decade. A stiff, starchy, awkward "prestige picture" that ends up just being laughable. In America is just the opposite. It is a lucid, heartfelt autobiographical piece by director Jim Sheridan, as told through the starry eyes of two repressible little Irish girls who move to America with their family in the 1980s. Never pandering, never sentimental, In America is an emotional powerhouse that knows just what buttons to push, without pushing too hard.

2002 Nominees:
Gangs of New York
The Hours
The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers
The Pianist

Remove: Gangs of New York
Replacement: Far From Heaven

I loved Gangs of New York But it just has too many problems to be Top 5 material...which is mainly the fault of the screenplay. Far From Heaven, Todd Haynes' luminous homage to Douglas Sirk, finds the depth and pain behind its beautiful, artificial facade, and is one of the most finely crafted, overlooked films of the decade.

2001 Nominees:
A Beautiful Mind
Gosford Park
In the Bedroom
The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring
Moulin Rouge

Remove: A Beautiful Mind
Replacement: Mulholland Drive
The Academy was so determined to award Ron Howard that they named A Beautiful Mind Best Picture of the Year, despite its rather middle of the road aesthetics. It's well done, yes, but at its core is conventional and overly sentimental. Which could never be said for David Lynch's brilliantly surreal masterpiece, Mulholland Drive, which is the very definition of original.

2000 Nominees:
Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon
Erin Brockovich
Remove: Erin Brockovich
Replacement: Dancer in the Dark
While Chocolat probably shouldn't have been nominated either, of Steven Soderbergh's 2000 output, Traffic is by far the stronger film, while Erin Brockovich is a more conventional film, even if it is a good one. Lars von Trier's Dancer in the Dark is a transcendent experience, a masterfully crafted film that honors and skewers musicals at the same time, while offering up a scathing critique of America's justice system. It is one of the great emotional cinematic experiences of my lifetime.


Popular Posts